![]() ![]() From a 2019 perspective, the Dumbo crow characters don’t hold up especially well, but it's worth noting that a full 27 years passed - after the initial release - until film critic Richard Shickel publicly scrutinized the infamous sequence in the book The Disney Version. Whereas Dumbo viewers and critics may have debated the questionable crow characters prior to the '60s, the Disney tradition and legacy seemingly overpowered the heaviest scrutiny. ![]() The name “Jim Crow” is the most obvious, of course, and the pack of controversial crows also sing a song called "When I See an Elephant Fly,” performed by Edwards and the Hall Johnson Choir. The moment is briefly referenced in Dumbo 2019 but not wholly re-created.ĭumbo 1941 includes a strong amount of questionable content. ![]() In addition, the Dumbo crow scene is preceded by a sequence where Dumbo and Timothy accidentally get drunk on champagne and proceed to hallucinate and see pink elephants. The first act includes “Song of the Roustabouts” which has faceless African-American characters working on the railroad, and using language that fits racial stereotypes. This results in a fiery escape plan that sees Dumbo eventually find a new home in his native East Asia.The 1941 Dumbo movie includes more than just one problematic sequence. Vandevere (Michael Keaton), Dumbo positioned as the star attraction to his Dreamland amusement park and all other acts fired. But whereas in 1941 that left him a pampered celebrity, in 2019 the next step and subsequent two acts is considerably grimmer the remake extends the story to have the circus bought by Edison/Disney parallel V. The first act of Dumbo 2019 is pretty much a straight remake of the original - down to the cartoonish train traveling across a map of the American South - with added segues for these new characters, charting Dumbo's life from birth to the unexpected flying reveal. In place of these staples comes a much more standard performing arts drama led by Colin Farrell's returning World War I veteran Holt Farrier and Danny DeVito's hard-pressed circus owner Max Medici (the only explicitly returning character, being an update of the original's ringmaster). Events are also transplanted from an assumed contemporary setting to 1919, presumably to give some real-world, pre-depression context to decisions regarding the elephant and his clan. Experience the magic of Disney’s live action film, Dumbo with the adorable Dumbo Fluttering Ears Press Dumbo’s foot to make his ears flap up and down to the. The biggest decision with Dumbo 2019 - especially in the context of the Disney - is the choice to remove all songs and talking animals. : How Dumbo 2019 Tries To "Fix" The Original.This Page: Dumbo's Big Changes (& What The Real Remake Purpose Is).Why have these changes been made and why do some go so granular? As such, rather than being a case where there are simply big differences to point out, there's something greater to be said about the underlying motivation of the intermittently faithful Dumbo 2019. And, to his credit, Burton's updated version does keep that at its core, even as the plot is massively expanded to the point that Dumbo 2019 is to Dumbo 1941 as Evil Dead II is to Evil Dead the same idea in a story that's so much bigger.ĭumbo is the most source-dissonant Disney remake since 2016's Pete's Dragon (and makes Burton's own quasi-sequel Alice in Wonderland from 2010 look positively faithful). A big-eared baby elephant who, following a series of punishing trials at a circus, discovers he can fly and becomes the premier attraction, Dumbo is in many ways made for Burton he's a social outsider with a whimsical talent that eventually makes him a hero.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |